Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
As we edge closer and closer to the 2024 Oscars, the likely winners of the four acting categories are slowly emerging. The Holdovers’s Da’Vine Joy Randolph looks unstoppable in the best supporting actress line-up, as, increasingly, does Oppenheimer’s Robert Downey Jr. in best supporting actor, while best actor seems poised to be a face off between the leading men of both of those movies, Paul Giamatti and Cillian Murphy. But there’s one race that’s even more stacked and far more difficult to predict—the only one which has the potential to yield a truly jaw-dropping result: best actress. Below, we present a rundown of the five runners and riders, as well as the hopefuls who narrowly missed out on a nomination.
The almost-contenders: Greta Lee, Margot Robbie, Natalie Portman, Fantasia Barrino, Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor
Firstly, a moment for those who so nearly made it onto the shortlist; five women who, in a marginally less competitive year, could have easily made up the full cohort jostling for the top prize. Their omissions, unjust as they are, are also a testament to the unbelievable strength of this year’s best actress line-up.
You have Past Lives’s Greta Lee, of course, who delivered a tender and touching bilingual performance—one which many critics, in the wake of the film’s Sundance premiere over a year ago, initially predicted would win her an Oscar.
Alongside her is Barbie’s Margot Robbie, whose snub has been much-discussed—a nod for her seemed almost guaranteed right up until the nominations announcement, and her progressive transformation from grinning plastic doll to gynaecologist appointment-booking human woman is certainly remarkable. (Some consolation can be found in the fact that she’s at least nominated in the best picture category for her role as a producer on the billion-dollar blockbuster.)
There’s also May December’s Natalie Portman, who gave what is still one of my favourite performances of 2023 as the preening, heartless indie actress who carelessly tosses a grenade into the life of the real woman she’s about to play. Her meticulously observed, deliciously devilish portrayal is on par with (if not even better than) her Oscar-winning work in Black Swan but, alas, the Academy appeared to be alienated by the film’s depiction of ruthlessly exploitative actors and awarded it only one nomination, for best original screenplay. Still, I’m convinced that Portman’s slippery turn will be remembered as one of the best of her career, and studied in acting classes for years to come.
Then there’s The Color Purple’s Fantasia Barrino, who had what once seemed to be a winning narrative: an American Idol breakout who dazzled critics and audiences alike as the all-singing, all-dancing center of gravity in a big-screen musical extravaganza, à la Academy Award winner Jennifer Hudson (who, coincidentally, placed seventh on the same season of the hit reality show which Barrino won). Danielle Brooks landed a well-deserved best supporting actress nod for the film—proving Academy voters did see and appreciate at least some aspects of the adaptation, despite leaving it out of several categories in which it was expected to show up—but in the end, Barrino was, sadly, overlooked.
Also deserving of more acknowledgment is Origin’s Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor, who embodies Pulitzer Prize winner Isabel Wilkerson in all her complexity as she grieves her mother and husband, sets off on an epic quest to fine-tune her thesis on racial injustice, and tirelessly works on the book which would go on to change her life, Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents. Steely and vulnerable, rigorously academic and serious but also quick to laugh (especially when hanging out with her exuberant cousin, as played by Niecy Nash-Betts), she’s someone who could have been an enigma, but in Ellis-Taylor’s hands, feels achingly real. A shame, then, that both her performance and the film as a whole was snubbed.
The veteran: Annette Bening
And so we come to the five nominees for 2024, each with their own distinct awards-season story—and some would argue that Bening’s is the most powerful. At 65, the American actor has given what is undoubtedly one of the best performances of her more-than-three-decade-long career in Nyad, and despite four previous Oscar nominations—for The Grifters, American Beauty, Being Julia, and The Kids Are All Right—she has never won before. If anyone was owed a statuette for their career more broadly, it’s surely her.
It also helps that her narrative mirrors that of her character, Diana Nyad, the long-distance swimmer who was 60 and had largely been written off by the public when she became determined to fulfil her lifelong goal of swimming from Cuba to Florida without a shark cage. “You’re never too old to chase your dreams,” she declares in the film’s rousing final scene, one which feels destined to end up as an Oscar clip, and will surely appeal to the Academy’s numerous older voters. She also ticks so many of the boxes that often feel like a prerequisite for an Oscar win—she’s playing a real person, doing something physically strenuous, and undergoing a dramatic transformation, as her character becomes more sunburned and injury-ridden—but simultaneously manages to make Diana Nyad feel like so much more than simply an inspirational figurehead, revelling in her hotheadedness and solipsism.
It’s never safe to count out the veteran—remember when Frances McDormand scooped the best actress prize for Nomadland in 2021, the year when everyone thought the race was between Viola Davis and Carey Mulligan?—but the only thing that’s likely to prevent Bening from winning is the fact that her truly great performance is competing against four utterly exceptional ones.
The industry stalwart: Carey Mulligan
Which brings us to Mulligan, who in Maestro*—*yes, another Netflix biopic—gives one of the most extraordinary performances I’ve ever seen as the luminous wife of Leonard Bernstein, Felicia Montealegre. She’s captivating from the second she steps on screen, but as the pressures of their marriage slowly weigh her down, her veneer of good-natured dutifulness begins to chip. We see her frustrations, her crushing disappointments, and her simmering anger slowly bubble to the surface, as well as her wistful realisation that, even with everything she’s already endured, she will still almost certainly spend the rest of her life devoting herself to this man. Then, she suddenly falls ill, and Mulligan is nothing short of virtuosic in her portrayal of an increasingly frail Felicia reaching the end of her life, her previous affection for her loved ones giving way to crankiness and exasperation. Her work is as subtle as it is emotionally devastating.